Call us — 0131 202 0491
Mon–Fri · 9am–5:30pm · No fix, no fee
Start a free diagnostic →
Guide · from the South Gyle bench

From the postbag: the DiskStation letters, answered properly.

The concept of networked storage generates a specific type of email. It tends to be longer and technically based, written by someone who followed the instructions provided in the user's manual and still experienced some harm. Below are two actual examples of this from our archives (the identifying details have been removed), each answered the way the bench addresses them today.

two decades’ experience
In-house, never outsourced
Only pay if we recover your data, on most jobs
// the diskstation letters

One box, two disasters.

A photo library that has been damaged along with failing hard disks in succession: what a NAS (Network Attached Storage) actually protects against.

Twins
Drives age the same
Network writes
Corrupt libraries fastest
Copy first
Never rebuild live
NAS ≠ backup
The core lesson
// letter one

‘My iPhoto library on the NAS corrupted…’

“I keep my iPhoto library on a Synology DiskStation 413J so the whole family can reach the photos. After a power cut the library won’t open — iPhoto says it’s corrupted and offers to rebuild, but the rebuild hangs. The photos seem to be in there when I browse the folders, but thousands have odd names and the albums are gone. Have we lost the organisation of fifteen years?”

Today's answer: most likely you have not lost everything, but stop hitting “Rebuild”. A photo library contains two parts: the actual images and an application database that has information about all your albums, edits and organisation. A power failure will most likely damage this application database before it damages the images, especially if you store them as part of a networked setup and use applications such as iPhoto, which were never designed to work over a network (interrupted writes to a library on a share are the classic corruption recipe). The repeated attempts to rebuild this damaged database corrupt it even further. The proper approach should be to first copy the entire library directory without changing anything to some form of local storage. Then, once the copy is safe from damage, attempt to fix the issues with the new copy using a recovery process which allows the database to recover lost information, or at least associate fifteen years of photos with their original dates. From now on, you may want to keep all your photos stored on your Network Attached Storage device (NAS) but do not allow a photo editing application to write directly to it for its working database.

// letter two

‘The drives are failing one after another…’

“My Synology started beeping about a degraded volume. I replaced the drive it flagged and during the rebuild a second drive started showing errors. Now the volume is ‘crashed’ and support says restore from backup — the NAS was the backup. Why would drives that were fine for years suddenly all fail together?”

Today's answer: because they weren't fine. They were identical twins: exact same model, exact same batch number, purchased on the same date, ran for the same hours, wore the same amount. If one goes over the edge into failure, its twin is right there with it, and rebuilding is likely the most painful week of a disk's life as far as reading is concerned; that's why the second failure so often occurs while the array is being rebuilt. Where you are now: shut it off, remove the disks labelled by bay, get a quote first, either by phone or using the form, and then send them (if the disks won't come out, send the NAS itself). A failed volume on top of disks with errors is a common recovery scenario for our bench each week, and usually a recoverable one if no further rebuild is attempted. There is an entire guide to "why together?" in this knowledge base.

// the pattern

What the DiskStation letters teach.

NAS boxes centralise risk at the same time as they appear to disperse it: all of the drives are in one box and age as if they were twin siblings, applications write their own databases across a network, and there's an alert light for "backup" that makes you feel safer. The most important thing the letters have in common is what we should be framing: a NAS is where your data resides, not a place that keeps your data safe. Being safe means having another copy of the data somewhere that cannot be affected by the first copy's disasters.

// if this is you

The bench is a phone call away.

Your DiskStation may be beeping, degraded or holding a photo library which will not open: don't wait to get the rebuild done before you get this diagnostic. This diagnostic is free. Your quote from us will always be fixed in writing. And, of course, we'll give you honest advice, at no charge, on 0131 202 0491.

0131 202 0491