Call us — 0131 202 0491
Mon–Fri · 9am–5:30pm · No fix, no fee
Start a free diagnostic →
Guide · from the South Gyle bench

From the postbag: two dying drives, answered properly.

Our laboratory archives hold many years of first emails: those which are sent by individuals in the hour they realise that something is wrong. Below are two such examples of these very first emails as they were received (with details that may allow identification omitted), as between them, they show half of the errors and most of the concerns which we meet here every week. Following each example: our response today.

two decades’ experience
In-house, never outsourced
Only pay if we recover your data, on most jobs
// the two letters

Two instincts, both wrong.

Chkdsk on a clicking drive and a shop's death sentence: the archive's most common mistakes.

2 days
Of chkdsk, before stopping
“No drive found”
Not the same as gone
Image first
Before any repair tool
Free
Second opinion
// letter one

‘I’ve been running chkdsk for two days…’

“My old IBM Aptiva won’t boot into Windows any more. I’ve been running chkdsk /r on the drive and it’s been going for two days now, stuck at the same percentage. Sometimes it finds errors and fixes them, then it hangs again. I can hear the drive making a sort of quiet clicking. I just want to copy my documents and photos off to DVD before it dies completely — is there a way to make chkdsk finish?”

Today's answer: please turn off your computer now, even if you have to cut yourself short. Chkdsk /r is designed as a file system fixer when working on good hardware; run on a disk with bad sectors and clicking heads, however, chkdsk will be running through each sector repeatedly (including those in death throes), and may go on for an extended period of time. The fixes reported by chkdsk can even move data from sectors which it misread off into other sectors: in other words, corruption with a progress bar. The quiet clicks coming from the hard drive are what reveal the real problem: mechanical issues. In the 2020s, the updated version of "burn these files onto DVD before they die" is a gentle, hardware-managed disk image which reads your poorly performing sectors last, and after two days of chkdsk, this drive urgently needs one.

// letter two

‘The shop says no hard drive found…’

“My HP Pavilion stopped booting and shows ‘no hard drive found’ on a black screen. A forum said the drive is dead and the data’s gone, and the local shop said the same — they can fit a new drive but the old one is scrap. It had all my son’s baby photos on it. Is it really hopeless, or is it worth a second opinion before I let them bin it?”

Today's answer: it is absolutely worth seeking a second opinion on this issue, and do not allow the drive to be sent to a bin. A 'no hard drive found' message simply indicates that there is no communication with the drive, not that the information is lost. Behind the "no hard drive found" error lie numerous types of fault, ranging from simple issues such as dead circuit boards, spindle failure or corrupted firmware through to more serious problems. An honest "we cannot" response by a repair service is very far from a "no one can" response. Replacing a drive and recovery of data from an older drive are two distinctly separate trade skills. That is precisely why free diagnostic services exist for the baby pictures and other precious memories: the price of finding out what you have will always be nothing, but the price of sending your precious memory devices to the bin will forever be everything.

// the pattern

What both letters share.

Different generations of hardware with the same impulse: continue to work on the patient, believe the closest decision will be correct, and use the final hours of that data to test. A technician's opposing impulses are why technicians exist: turn off the power first, then make an image before any repair, and get your answers from the person who has made their career out of making decisions. Each instructional manual within this resource library is essentially a long form of these three statements.

// if this is you

The bench is a phone call away.

If either letter could have been your own, then stop where the writer of that letter should have stopped. The diagnostic is free, the quote is fixed in writing, and as much honest guidance as we can offer on a call to 0131 202 0491 will cost you nothing.

0131 202 0491