Call us — 0131 202 0491
Mon–Fri · 9am–5:30pm · No fix, no fee
Start a free diagnostic →
Guide · from the South Gyle bench

When a MacBook drive fails.

‘MacBook hard drive failure’, in essence, refers to two completely different types of computers. Older MacBooks and iMacs (those with a removable drive) are similar to any other machine when it comes to a drive failure; there is a physical device that can fail or recover. Modern Macs, however, have their storage soldered onto the logic board, and it is also encrypted by default. Therefore, when an encrypted Mac fails, the term ‘failure’ means something different than it does for a non-encrypted computer. What you do next determines if you will be able to access the data. Knowing which kind of Mac you have changes the whole job.

two decades’ experience
In-house, never outsourced
Only pay if we recover your data, on most jobs
// know your machine

Old Mac, new Mac: not the same job.

The route of recovery splits at one point: whether the drive is separate from the motherboard, or soldered to the board and encrypted.

Older Macs
Removable drive
2018+ / Apple silicon
Soldered, encrypted
Fusion Drive
Two halves, one volume
FileVault
Key or nothing
// the older macs

The removable-drive era.

Most MacBooks made up to about 2015, and numerous iMacs, have a 2.5-inch hard drive or an SSD which can be removed and replaced as needed. This is common storage within a typical Apple casing. It will fail normally: when you bang into the computer causing mechanical failure of the drive (the clicking or grinding), when it's been used long enough that the parts wear out naturally, or when an SSD drops out of the system and stops being seen. None of these are unique to Apple products. Therefore, the methods to recover your data follow the same process as recovering data from most other types of computers: use donor heads for physical mechanical failures, repair a dead SSD controller, obtain a sector image, and finally obtain the files from the copy. If your Mac is a few years old and the drive spins, this is almost certainly your situation, and the odds are good.

// the modern reality

Soldered, encrypted, and unforgiving.

From about 2018 (when Apple’s T2 chip arrived), and on all Apple Silicon machines since, the SSD has been soldered to the logic board, and the data is encrypted by default, with the keys stored internally within the chip. There is no “drive” to pull. If the logic board or its storage controller fails, you will need board-level repair to access your data, something we would never attempt (and we inform you of this prior to receiving any unit); and if the encryption keys are also lost with the failure of the chip, then even an intact flash memory can show absolutely nothing. This is exactly why a current MacBook that refuses to start up is substantially different from an older model, and why 'simply wipe clean and install OS again to correct' may well be the most destructive action possible for someone who wishes to recover their data.

// the fusion drive trap

Fusion Drive: two disks pretending to be one.

A large number of iMac and Mac mini systems were sold with a Fusion Drive installed, which combines a relatively small solid state drive (SSD) and larger hard disk drive into a single virtual volume, so that it may feel like you are working on a fast computer while still holding an enormous amount of information. When either part of this single logical unit fails, the entire volume can refuse to mount, and since your files are spread across both sides, both components must be physically copied (imaging), and then the original volume must be rebuilt from those images in order for your files to become accessible again. This same problem exists with the use of RAID arrays or other similar technologies where data is divided among multiple disks; individual disks do not provide useful access to data.

// signs and mistakes

The signs, and the three mistakes.

Warning signs vary with the type of machine being used: if you're using an older Mac with a spinning hard drive that is clicking, beeping or crawling; if your Mac boots to a flashing question mark or stays stuck on the Apple logo; if your Time Machine backups begin to fail, or if you open Disk Utility and see one of your disks marked as failing. Whichever sign you experience, the common mistakes will always be the same. Do not repeatedly restart a failing computer in hopes that it will eventually catch (each additional startup consumes some amount of your failing drive's remaining life or increases stress on your dying motherboard). Do not continue to run "Disk Utility First Aid" repeatedly or go looking for "Erase" on a disk you still need to use: on a current Mac model, erasure can delete the encryption key, and the data is then gone forever. Also do not assume that your Time Machine backup will restore until you confirm it does so.

// how recovery works

A copy first, always.

No matter which Mac, the order will hold. Old machines: fix the mechanism or controller, take a complete read-only image, and rebuild your files from the copied version, leaving the original unaltered. To get at the storage on the newer soldered Macs' boards, you'd need board-level access, working with the encryption where the keys still exist rather than fighting it. That's work we're not going to accept. We tell you this before you send us anything. The Mac recovery station works on APFS, FileVault and Fusion volumes as just another thing in our line of work, but again the first step in every case is copying, not trying to "fix" the last remaining data.

// if this is you

The bench is a phone call away.

Clicking, or stuck at the Apple logo on your MacBook or iMac? Or does your Fusion Drive just refuse to be mounted? Stop before you wipe everything clean or reinstall anything. We take the drive, not the whole computer. And we do not have a service for storage soldered directly onto the motherboard. The diagnostic is free. Your price quote will be fixed and written in black and white. Honest advice is always complimentary as well. Call us today at 0131 202 0491.

0131 202 0491