Call us — 0131 202 0491
Mon–Fri · 9am–5:30pm · No fix, no fee
Start a free diagnostic →
Guide · from the South Gyle bench

Shucking, and the bridge-board trap.

The "pull the bare drive" solution is everyone's favourite answer when there are problems with an external drive, and half the time it is even correct: the case was faulty, therefore take apart the case, pull the bare drive, connect it directly, back up your data. However, the other half of the time, the drive is plugged in correctly, yet it still produces only noise. This article is about that half, and is intended for those people who would like to know which half they fall under before attempting to open their unit.

two decades’ experience
In-house, never outsourced
Only pay if we recover your data, on most jobs
// the hidden chip

Some enclosures encrypt by default.

Remove the "bridge" board from some of your external drives, and all of your data will appear to be complete random nonsense: the encryption board held the key.

Always on
No toggle, no prompt
Keep both
Board and drive together
Never format
The ‘unreadable’ drive
Sealed unit
Treat as one
// the hidden chip

Encryption you never switched on.

The little USB bridge board inside many of the popular mainstream external hard drives (Western Digital My Passport being the most well-known example, and several of Seagate's ranges) does more than just convert the type of connector: it encrypts all information going across the board using hardware based encryption at all times. There is no checkbox for this, there is no request for a password anywhere, nor is it mentioned on the packaging; the drive behind it stores ciphertext, and the encryption key resides with the board. Throw away the case of the external hard drive, plug the unenclosed bare drive directly into a computer, and every sector appears to be completely normal, healthy gibberish: the drive itself is perfectly good, the data itself is perfectly good, but you threw away the one device which can read what's stored on the drive. Add a password to the drive's software interface, and the encryption scheme becomes even deeper.

// triage before tools

Which half are you in?

Prior to using any screwdriver, identify the patient. Retail branded externals from the encrypting families should be treated as sealed units: the enclosure, board and drive stay together. This is due to the fact that the board could be the key holder. Most desktop docks and all generic enclosures you have built yourself will pass data straight through, so shucking these is generally safe. If you've already shucked and received gibberish: stop, and above all don't format the 'unreadable' drive. Reunite it with its original board (dead included), get a quote first, by phone or with the form, then bring the whole family in, with its cable and power supply (Monday to Friday 9am to 5:30pm, with no appointment needed); bench recovery works through the proper decryption channel, and damaged bridges can often be repaired or their key material worked with. The external drive page has a standing rule: send both halves, always.

// the wider lesson

Convenience features are load-bearing.

The bridge-board trap generalises, and applies equally well today to all forms of modern storage, whether an external drive or a network attached storage (NAS) device. Modern storage devices are filled with the invisible machinery that your data depends upon. Examples include a data store's encryption mechanism being contained within the device's enclosure, the key for unlocking a volume encrypted by BitLocker having been escrowed to an account that you cannot remember, an Apple storage device tied to its logic board, or a volume stored on a NAS device that has no significance without the RAID metadata that describes how it was constructed. The pattern's moral is easy to adhere to, but ignoring it is very costly: when a storage device fails, save everything that makes up the failed device, including circuit boards, enclosures, caddies, the lot. In the age of hardware security, what you throw away may be the last piece of information needed to access the data contained within that piece of equipment.

// if this is you

The bench is a phone call away.

You’ve shucked a drive and found nonsensical characters, or you're about to open one and you are wondering which half you are in? There's no charge for our diagnostic. Our quotation will be fixed and written out clearly. Honest opinions regarding your recovery options cost you nothing when calling us on 0131 202 0491.

0131 202 0491